The pending breakthrough climate, tax and healthcare bill could revive his popularity — or not.
A week ago, conventional wisdom in Washington held that Joe Biden’s presidency was in a profound crisis. A drumbeat intensified for the aging president not to run for a second term. But by the weekend, that narrative was upended as it once again became clear that he is accumulating a remarkable set of legislative achievements in short order and under difficult circumstances.
The sudden jolt was the announcement late last week that Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and the most conservative Democratic senator, Joe Manchin of West Virginia, agreed to major spending on healthcare, taxation and climate change. If the bill passes – as seems highly likely since Republicans cannot block budgetary measures – Mr Biden will endure the paradox of having passed a vast array of popular legislation while retaining dismal poll numbers.
Republicans are outraged that the agreement was kept completely secret, including from most Democrats and the press. For weeks, Democratic leaders insisted internal negotiations were ongoing, but carefully crafted the impression of an impasse.
Not wanting to allow Mr Biden too many successes, Republicans relied on this misdirection when they supported a $280 billion spending package to bolster American microchip manufacturing and other technological development. Aimed primarily at strengthening the nation’s technological and economic competition with China, it is the largest US industrial policy initiative in decades. It is also so evidently in the national interest that it should have been adopted without controversy or subsequent recriminations.
As soon as it passed, Democratic leaders announced that not only were their internal negotiations successful, Mr Manchin had agreed to a far bigger package than he led people to believe he might. It is the latest chunk of Mr Biden’s fraught Build Back Better program, a transformational agenda so sweeping it could not be passed in its totality, but much of which is instead being implemented piecemeal.
Last year, a huge infrastructure bill was broken away and adopted. When Mr Manchin insisted on a large reduction in overall spending on the rest of the package, and ruled out several key features including childcare, the project was generally given up for dead.
Now Democrats seem poised to pass another major chunk of the original highly ambitious agenda, and it will have a gigantic impact. Most strikingly, it will put the US on track to meet globally crucial climate change goals that had been considered politically unachievable.
Reversing decades of severe underfunding, the package provides major support to the beleaguered Internal Revenue Service, and that should finance the collection of untold billions in unpaid taxes. It imposes a minimum 15 percent tax on the wealthiest corporations, many of which pay nothing at all, and higher taxes on “carried interest” exemptions enjoyed by the likes of private equity and hedge fund managers. Former president Donald Trump will surely be infuriated at the elimination of “pass-through” loopholes that apparently allowed him to often pay virtually no income tax.
Government health providers will finally be allowed to negotiate prices with pharmaceutical companies, saving billions and greatly reducing drug costs. And the US would inch closer to universal healthcare coverage.
Some Republicans, infuriated at being suckered – although only into supporting obviously necessary legislation – are lashing out by withdrawing support for aid to military veterans exposed to toxic burn pits in Afghanistan and Iraq, and for legislation guaranteeing marriage equality. Both bills are overwhelmingly popular, so Republicans are being provoked into irrational and, in all likelihood, self-destructive retaliation.
Democrats not only completely outfoxed and bamboozled the Republicans, by cannily marketing the bill – accurately enough – as the “Inflation Reduction Act of 2022,” they have emphasised how overwhelmingly popular virtually all its provisions and their impacts are likely to be.
Build Back Better was an ineffective legislative program not because its provisions were largely unpopular – although it originally included regressive forms of student loan relief, and state and local tax benefits that favour the better off. Rather, it was simply too vast and sprawling to be comprehensible and, as a unified bundle, provoked powerful sticker shock regarding its total costs.
But broken into discrete chunks, and with some key elements, both good and bad, jettisoned, much of the original plan seems likely to be eventually enacted. Only Arizona Senator Kyrsten Sinema, another frequently uncooperative Democrat, might prevent passage, but it seems unlikely that she would ultimately thwart Mr Manchin’s breakthrough.
The biggest question is what impact this sprawling legislation and dynamic governance will have in both the November midterms and the next presidential election in 2024.
Inflation, and the economic slowdown now being engineered by the Federal Reserve to control it, will certainly prove a millstone. But Democrats can and should run on this extraordinary record of legislative achievement: $1.9 trillion in pandemic relief, $1.2 trillion for hard infrastructure, $280 billion for industrial investment, and now apparently, $700 billion for healthcare, taxation and climate change.
Add to that the first gun control legislation in decades, an upcoming measure to repair the badly-worded and anachronistic Electoral Count Act (which Mr Trump tried to exploit to retain power despite losing the 2020 election), plus another to protect marriage equality, and the legislative checklist is extremely impressive and, in theory at least, highly popular.
Much of what Democrats want remains undone, of course, but this massively exceeds any rational expectations. However, as I recently noted in these pages, Mr Biden has been downright atrocious at messaging.
In November, Republicans will be running primarily on inflation, and racial and cultural grievances, which are powerful emotional motivators. Yet they have nominated so many extremists, crackpots and charlatans in key Senate races that Democrats may well retain control. But Republicans seem equally poised to regain a majority in the House of Representatives.
Mr Biden’s legislative agenda would then surely be frozen, especially since many Republicans are now so enraged that they claim to regret having supported almost anything he proposed, no matter how basic and reasonable. But the president would still go into a re-election campaign in 2024 with an outstanding list of first-term legislative accomplishments he is already in the process of accumulating.
If Americans want their government to function, provide services and strengthen the country, under current circumstances Democrats – being the only party, at least at the national level, truly interested in policy and governance – have an unassailable case. They can bolster that by stoking reasonable fears that Republicans are stripping citizens of fundamental freedoms, particularly given the sudden and shocking wave of near-total abortion restrictions in many states.
But if voters prefer emotional release and high-octane entertainment, Republicans could regain power through the potent and resonant performative theatrics which has become their disgraceful stock-in-trade.
Americans are going to have to decide if they really want good government or a good show.